ETHOS


I’m appalled. No, it is not OK to draw Michelle Obama strung up on a tree.
May 24, 2008, 8:23 pm
Filed under: Chloe, Current Events, Race | Tags: ,

By Chloe Wayne

I’m a little late on this, but check out this photo a blogger at Daily Kos, “the largest progressive community blog in the United States,” made and posted on the site (only to be taken down hours later):

What can be worse than the overt racist is the well-meaning, “colorblind” white liberal who is “down for the cause” but is seriously ignorant. I was shocked to find that the blogger in question posted the photo as a medium of support for Michelle Obama, and an attack against the Republican Party for their campaign tactics. The person even wrote underneath it: “Copy and send out as you wish.” Are you serious??????

In the question of Black freedom, the textbook answers are 1863 and 1964: the years of the Emancipation Proclamation and a landmark Civil Rights Act, respectively. But when, if ever, have we been emancipated from the mental and psychological stronghold our racially muddied history has had on us? It boggles my mind that the poster could not foresee people’s outrage at such an image, as if the pain of such atrocities no longer weighs heavily on our hearts and minds, as if racism and white supremacy are vestigial flickers of decades past that bear no implications for today.

James Baldwin once railed against that brand of conventional wisdom in a letter to his nephew marking the centennial anniversary of emancipation: “You know, and I know, that the country is celebrating one hundred years of freedom one hundred years too soon. We cannot be free until they are free” (my italics). The they he refers to are “the innocents”—some of whom are our amicable and ostensibly non-racist (white) countrymen, oblivious to the continued causal correlation between black skin and plight. They are not free because they have yet to understand and fully grapple with their history that continues to shape their present. Why are they oblivious? Why don’t they understand? Because the days of slavery have passed, and according to Baldwin, they weren’t allowed to talk about its ills anymore.

His words ring true today, almost 50 years later, when the daughters and grandsons of those 1960s liberals proudly carry on family tradition, oblivious to inescapable ways that race continues to color America’s identity (no pun intended). Why are they oblivious? The days of de jure racism have passed, so we’re not allowed to talk about race anymore, of course. And now, we have aspiring graphic artists-slash-pundits running rampant with their designs on a blog that gets 600,000 hits a day…because, quite simply, they don’t know any better.

I mean, lynching is so last century, right? So that means white bloggers who have exhausted the conventional political pandering methods for titillating their audiences are allowed to reappropriate images of America’s homegrown terrorists branding and lynching a Black woman (none other than FIRST LADY-HOPEFUL MICHELLE OBAMA)…right?

Wrong. Aside from the many other issues this brilliant horribly misguided Photoshop idea brings to the fore, the salient one, for me, is that America’s obsessive footrace to distance itself from its heinous past (and, let’s be honest, its not so pleasant present) has proven triumphant. People seem to believe the past is, well, the past, and that the passage of time sufficiently obscures our connection to things we would rather forget, such as lynching and the Ku Klux Klan. And consequently, they are horribly careless with the ways they remember and reference them.

Again, Baldwin will say it much better than I can: “It is a sentimental error to believe that the past is dead; it means nothing to say that it is all forgotten, that the Negro himself has forgotten it. It is not a question of memory. Oedipus did not remember the thongs that bound his feet; nevertheless the marks they left testified to that doom toward which his feet were leading him” (Notes of a Native Son). Today, Black folk may not be strung up on trees every week, but the scars from Jim Crow certainly still sting, not least because we have yet to quash the forces and structures that sanction excessive brutality as a form of “policing” Blacks.

America has insisted on forgetting this part of its past, at the expense of those trying—impossibly—to heal. And we have pretended that its relative omission from history books and quotidian conversation can sever our ties to it; it is normal and normative to believe America’s history of racism is a non-issue today. So as a result, Barack Obama’s invocations of race in his campaign are supposed to be aberrant missteps for “playing the race card”…

…and a white blogger, in defense of the Obamas (are you serious???), fails to see his error in posting such an abomination. I’m appalled.


5 Comments so far
Leave a comment

Great post and it definitely demonstrates insanely questionable judgment that they ran that image.

Also, what’s with her eroticized naked white back? For a minute I thought I was looking at Miley Cyrus in Vanity Fair.

This reminded me of two old Oh Word articles which had accompanying art that similarly employed ironic (but far less incendiary) use of loaded racial imagery in a cavalier fashion.

This Ice Cube feature and this Devin the Dude one both shifted their rapper subjects into crafty animals of old folk tales: Cube as a fox stealing a bunch of records from a magpie and Devin the Dude hopping along as Brer Rabbit through some master’s field.

I remember discussing this with Oh Word staff at the time and we were worried about the potential for negative response to these images. We deliberated over them and ultimately decided it was ok to go forward with them because the subjects invited this kind of dissection. Ice Cube’s persona based on racial controversy, Devin’s song based on a Brer Rabbit tale.. and both rappers very comfortable in their use of irony.

If I may remember right, we ended up not getting a single criticism about the images. Which just goes to show you, nobody reads our site anyway so we were just wasting our time on those discussions.

Still, I wonder if anyone deliberated over at Daily Kos.

Comment by rafi

Nice blog. I can’t stand when classmates say things like: “race is no longer an issue”…”blacks are just lazy”…”blacks always blame the past without looking at themselves”..etc.

I believe that the future can become alot brighter one day for all races to truly come together. But, with pictures like this, that day is simply a long way away. I think that people have to get rid of their ignorance and actually look around and see that less than 1% of CEOs are black, the average income for an African-American in the U.S. is less than $10,000 per year in a “land of opportunity.” In order to look ahead and move ahead, we must not forget out past (whites and blacks alike), and take significant steps to actually change it. Not half-ass steps like the one who posted the picture. Once people actually reflect on all of the facts and try to do something to change it (such as making us more aware with blogs such as this), then we can try to move ahead and make MLK’s dream a reality. Until then, this is what we’re going to continue to see. Great blog!

Comment by Perk

Somehow i missed the point. Probably lost in translation :) Anyway … nice blog to visit.

cheers, Submerge

Comment by Submerge

It is a very good insight. The same kind of error led to the cover of the New Yorker. It’s as if some people just don’t get it. I caused a stir when my father became a pastor in Tyler, Texas, because our Sunday School teacher was talking against “mixed marriages” and I said that without them I would not exist. My father spent that Sunday afternoon answering phone calls and telling people that my mother is mostly Cherokee. But even if she weren’t I can read both history and the news. It is not just a memory of times gone by; after James Bird was killed in Jasper, a hate crimes bill was passed by the ever-conservative Texas Legislature, and Governor B*sh vetoed it, saying that “all crimes are hate crimes.” Like so many others of his race, he just did not get it (or more likely, just did not care). Thankfully, those who “don’t get it” seem to be a minority themselves. As Robert Kennedy said, when announcing Dr King’s assassination, “The vast majority of white people and the vast majority of black people in this country want to live together, want to improve the quality of our life, and want justice for all human beings that abide in our land.” Even a mixed breed person like myself can understand that.

Comment by David Roland Strong

Wow, you call the person that posted that pic uneducated. but you are acting like racism doesnt exist any more. You must not make it to the south very often. I live in the south, I am white. And I see racism on a daily basis. And it goes all ways, whites against blacks, blacks against whites, both against hispanic, and hispanic against both. You seriously need to educate yourself on the current state of this country before calling someone else uneducated.

Comment by jharrod




Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>